The most profitable plants in your vegetable garden

It may be impossible to put a price on the satisfaction of bringing in a basket of produce fresh from your garden.  As well as the enhanced flavors from having truly fresh produce from your garden compared to that of your local supermarket.  Though when I was harvesting my potatoes this summer with my daughter I did have the thought, “Would it have been smarter for me to grow something else in this space?”  I estimate out of the 4-5 square feet I used for these plants I probably got about $4-5 worth of potatoes.

I did a little research first to determine yields of various plants per square foot and secondly what the value (organic supermarket prices USD) of the yielded produce at harvest.  Given I am a city dweller with a fairly small footprint for my vegetable garden (about 30-35 square feet) making decisions on what to buy at the supermarket and what to grow in the garden may be a huge money saver.

Now from the results below you can see the winners for the most produce value per square foot are many of the leafy green vegetables/herbs (cilantro, lettuce, chives, dill, Swiss chard) next comes many of the larger vine plants (tomatoes, squash, pumpkins, peas) with many of the root plants taking up the rear.  Now much of this makes sense where many of the vine plants grow on trellises and are allowed to spread, which I guess is sort of cheating the square foot rule but I will let it slide.  Compared to the root plants whose production is entirely dependent on the space allowed in square footage they have to grow as well as these are normally inexpensive produce items to begin with.

Vegetable USD Value/SF
Cilantro $ 21.20
Arugula-Roquette $ 20.92
Green Salad Mix $ 17.55
Chives $ 16.40
Dill $ 16.40
Lettuce $ 16.20
Tomato, Cherry, small & medium $ 15.57
Turnip $ 9.90
Tomato, large $ 9.50
Squash, Winter $ 8.40
Tomatillo $ 8.00
Cucumber $ 7.74
Basil $ 6.63
Radish, Red $ 6.22
Pumpkin $ 6.20
Chard, Swiss $ 6.14
Celery $ 6.00
Squash, Summer $ 5.96
Choi $ 5.70
Peas, Snow $ 4.50
Pepper, Jalapeño $ 4.50
Squash, Summer, Zucchini $ 4.17
Onion, Bunching $ 4.14
Pepper, Bell $ 3.60
Brussels Sprouts $ 3.59
Carrots $ 3.56
Rhubarb $ 3.25
Squash, Winter, Butternut $ 3.20
Kale $ 3.07
Grass, Lemon $ 3.00
Peas, English $ 3.00
Onion, Bulb $ 2.63
Radish, White $ 2.60
Bean, Bush $ 2.51
Peas, Edible Pod $ 2.50
Artichoke, Globe $ 2.40
Cabbage, Chinese Napa $ 2.24
Squash, Winter, Delicata $ 2.10
Spinach, Spring/Fall $ 1.80
Leeks $ 1.75
Potatoes $ 1.50
Parsnips $ 1.50
Garlic $ 1.37
Squash, Summer, Yellow $ 1.34
Parsley $ 1.31
Corn $ 1.25
Squash, Winter, Acorn $ 1.20
Squash, Winter, Hubbard $ 1.20
Eggplant $ 1.10
Greens, Mustard $ 1.10
Rutabaga $ 1.00
Beet $ 0.89
Cabbage, Savoy $ 0.80
Broccoli $ 0.80
Kohlrabi $ 0.75
Cauliflower $ 0.60
Broccoli, Chinese $ 0.60
Cabbage $ 0.50

Sources: http://www.mcgoodwin.net/pages/ppatch.html for plant yield information, http://shop.safeway.com for current produce prices

Now even with this information I will still plan on growing some onions and garlic since I more than likely would be forced to use dehydrated alternatives due to being too lazy to drive to the supe
rmarket to buy fresh varieties.  Though I may be adding some more herbs/greens to my garden this year. 

One important thing to remember is you still have to eat the vegetables, throwing $20 worth or arugula or cilantro into the compost bin is not exactly a sound investment.

Related posts:

  1. Planting seeds outside
  2. Vegetable gardening may not be "financially" profitable during your first season
  3. pH needs of plants in soil or hydroponics
  4. How to water your garden
  5. Earth Day in the garden
Posted on

45 Responses to “The most profitable plants in your vegetable garden”

  1. Johnice Says:

    Great information! This will help me in the next few week while I’m deciding what seeds to order for the coming seasons. It will also help me explain to others why I grow so much of this or that. Thanks!


  2. Plangarden Says:

    Thanks for posting this and the references to pricing. We grow two artichoke plants and have gotten at least $50 in one season from one $8 plant. After fertilizing and other costs of care, we’ll probably get a tenfold return on this little investment!


  3. Karen Says:

    Huh, wonder why so much for chard and so little for kale? Aren’t they both healthy/trendy at the moment? They take up the same space in my garden, or chard slightly more. Hm. Hey, was thinking of a Seattle garden bloggers meet-up some time here in the near future? Are you interested? If so, please stop by my blog and leave a comment about your availability. Happy New Year! – Karenhttp://greenwalks.wordpress.com/2009/01/02/seattle-area-garden-bloggers-meet-up/


  4. The Cheap Vegetable Gardener Says:

    I took a look at the numbers and Swiss Chard was $0.70 more per pound and supposedly should yeild an extra 0.8 lb per square foot. I want to do the numbers again with farmer market prices since the seasonal ones can vary.


  5. Anonymous Says:

    Ole Timey gardener here, I feed me and the wife for the bigger part from the garden. We dry a lot of the garden, and pressure can the rest for the long Canadian winters! We also recommend brewing beer and sauerkrauting cabbage.


  6. Molly Says:

    Cool cost analysis. You kind of have to figure in the cost of labor for planting, maintaining, harvesting, and preparing, which makes garlic a much better deal than, say, shelling peas.


  7. Anonymous Says:

    Thanks for all the work! My only question is whether you checked organic or conventional prices on the Safeway website.


  8. Anonymous Says:

    For those like me who are not from the USA/Canada and who had never seen the word “Cilantro” before, it’s what the rest of the world calls Coriander.


  9. The Cheap Vegetable Gardener Says:

    Molly, good point I don’t grow peas unless I can eat them whole. I can’t imagine making a profit shelling peas.I did use organic prices if they were available otherwise used conventional. I want to update when these vegetables are in season.Sorry always thought leaves were cilantro and seeds Coriander but your right that is just US/Canada. Just to have everyone covered also called dhania, Kothimbir, Kothimira, Kothambari, Kothamalli, kindza, Chinese parsley, and Mexican parsley


  10. Anonymous Says:

    Thanks for posting this useful table. I’m approaching value-per-square-foot from a little different perspective because I’m planning to sell some vegetables next season for the first time. I only have very limited land in town available so I need to think about maximizing my return per square foot.I’m a bit confused by the entry on the 10th line, first column, for winter squash at $8.40. Further down the list you also have three other winter squashes listed (butternut, hubbard and acorn) at much lower values per square foot. Is the first one some kind of gourmet winter squash that is valued higher? Or a higher yielding variety?Also, as you mentioned at the end of your post, to save money you have to eat what you grow. There’s no point in filling your entire garden with high value herbs that mostly go to waste. Better to use more of the space for lower valued crops that you will actually eat.Also, I have a book recommendation for you, check out:How to Grow More Vegetables and Fruits Than You Ever Thought Possible on Less Land Than You Can Imagine by John Jeavons It’s all about growing more veggies in less space. (The potential yield tables are particularly interesting.)


  11. Anonymous Says:

    There is a book by British gardening writer, Joy Larkcom, called “Grow Your Own Vegetables” (ISBN: 978-0711219632). Apart from being a mine of information – seasons, varieties, soil and temperature requirements – it has a value per space rating much like yours. That said, there are things you can grow that you simply can’t buy – ultra-fresh home-grown corn comes to mind.


  12. David LaFerney Says:

    Good information. As you mention the best value is to grow what you will eat – I would add that for best value concentrate on growing what you can eat fresh. Once you start factoring in the extra time and expense for canning and preserving returns start diminishing.Of course the thing is, since you can’t really buy an equivalent to home canned green beans (just to name one thing) you can’t make an accurate comparison.Part of the value of gardening is intrinsic.


  13. joe Says:

    To increase your potato yield in smaller spaces, you can grow vertically. Gradually add containing walls (old tires, barrel sections, open-end boxes etc) and more growing medium as the stems and leaves grow upwards. The green parts will produce more tubers when buried. Keep stacking, burying and letting the plant catch up. Eventually you’ll have a tower filled with potatoes which you can deconstruct and harvest.


  14. Red Icculus Says:

    I was looking for local hydro farms online. I came across one who grows the top 3 valuable crops for sale. They must have done their research.


  15. Anonymous Says:

    I would love to get all of the info but I can’t seem to get rid of the stupid ad that takes up the right hand information…I know it is most probably me but how do I get that to disappear so I can see all of the numbers. Thank you.


  16. The Cheap Vegetable Gardener Says:

    Anonymous, looks like the this was a result of the 3-column site redesign, everything should be showing up now. Sorry for the confusion.


  17. Anonymous Says:

    “For those like me who are not from the USA/Canada and who had never seen the word “Cilantro” before, it’s what the rest of the world calls Coriander. January 5, 2009 8:17 PM ” actually coriander is the seed or spice from the cilantro plant, it’s what the rest of the world knows and is laughing at you for.


  18. Log Homes Says:

    Great blog post! I love learning about this online as gardening/landscaping are not only hobbies of mine but I actually do a little bit of work like that during the summer months as a second job. I appreciate your content in your blog and wish that you would keep up the good work :)


  19. alex Says:

    Fabulous! Anyone have thoughts about including cost of irrigation for dry zones like No. California?


  20. The Cheap Vegetable Gardener Says:

    Alex, that is a good point. In general with a few exceptions irrigation is pretty consistent for most plants. The frequency might be more or less but the amounts should be similar. I would be curious what the cost to simply water a square foot of land is. Depending on the technique (drip, soaker, sprinkler, hand watering) costs could also vary.


  21. Ash Says:

    Hi, I'm just wondering what the time period is per square foot… for example, in one spring/summer season you can get two root crops, one fruit crop, or an ongoing supply of kale picked bit by bit. So is this data per season, or per harvest…? Thanks.


  22. The Cheap Vegetable Gardener Says:

    Ash, these numbers are for one harvest, so if you do spring/fall crops can double the profit.


  23. don Says:

    How can the lettuce give you so much per square foot when a head of lettuce takes up a square foot and depending on variety gets you .60 to 3.00a head???


  24. Mike’s Window | Says:

    [...] The most profitable plants in your vegetable garden. I don’t care, I’m still growing my broccoli and beets. [...]


  25. kbz Says:

    I haven’t been following your blog long enough to know whether you grow anything besides veggies, but the most profitable thing in my Seattle garden is surely raspberries. They grow like weeds and require very little tending. The fruit is so expensive in the store, and never as good as it is at home. Takes to freezing really well, too.


  26. The Cheap Vegetable Gardener Says:

    kbz, that is a great point fruit is definitely very profitable especially for fruits like blackberries I can pick all I want from the wild.


  27. Maximise Savings In A Small Garden By Selecting Profitable Plants | Lifehacker Australia Says:

    [...] The Most Profitable Plants in Your Garden [Cheap Vegetable Gardener via Re-Nest] Tagged:diygardeningoutdoorssaving money [...]


  28. Sammy Says:

    I find I save the most money in my garden by having a bay laurel tree. Go price fresh, organic whole bay leaves.


  29. John Says:

    Great info. Expect more comments now that Lifehacker has found you.

    What about shallots? Man those things are expensive but awfully easy to grow.


  30. How To Get the Most Bang For Your Buck From Your Garden - Three Ninety Eight Says:

    [...] Cheap Vegetable Gardener has taken out the guesswork for us by compiling a list determining the profitability of growing [...]


  31. The Cheap Vegetable Gardener Says:

    John, I just noticed the lifehacker mention. Guess we are in for another load test :)

    Shallots are a great example where the premature version can be grown even tighter. Actually this is on the list but under the sudo name “bunching onions”. If anyone doesn’t know what we am talking about we just did a post on shallots/green onions/spring onions… this morning


  32. RichardStep Says:

    Hello and thank you for this excellent veggie-ROI information! I just recently expanded my raised bed, square foot garden, and while I’ll say it’s fun to grow EVERYTHING – it sure is nice to know I could be more efficient at it. Not to mention I would plant cilantro in a pot all on it’s lonesome and not take up a precious square foot… that stuff grows like crazy! According to your list, my garden is a little on the inefficient side (check it out: http://richardstep.com/2010/05/25/square-foot-garden-update-irrigation-a-tomato/), but hey – now I know. Thank you again, kind soul!


  33. Chirpy Says:

    My veg growing has been reduced to 2 tomatoes, cucumbers, lettuce, cilantro, basil and kale. But I grow much more fruit than I used to: strawberries, raspberries, blueberries. All grow so well in Seattle.


  34. absurdist Says:

    While I appreciate the effort, I submit that your value scale is distorted by using Safeway’s prices as your baseline. Shopping produce markets and/or farmers’ markets changes the price structure dramatically, and offers fruit/veg more comparable to what you’d grow yourself in terms of freshness and quality.


  35. Con l’orto si risparmia: quali sono gli ortaggi più redditizi da coltivare? | FloraBlog - Il Blog dedicato al regno vegetale Says:

    [...] suona come “l’ortolano a buon mercato”) scrivendo un interessante post intitolato The most profitable plants in your vegetable garden (“Le piante più redditizie nel tuo orto”) dove ha pubblica un elenco di piante [...]


  36. Aaron Says:

    What about fennel?


  37. Best Money Tips: Most Profitable Plants for Small Gardens « Finance Blog Says:

    [...] Profitable Plants — The top three are cilantro, arugula-roquette, and green salad mix.  Cheap Vegetable Gardener via [...]


  38. Best Money Tips: Most Profitable Plants for Small Gardens | Finance News Says:

    [...] Profitable Plants — The top three are cilantro, arugula-roquette, and green salad mix.  Cheap Vegetable Gardener via [...]


  39. The Cheap Vegetable Gardener Says:

    absurdist, I have thought about that which probably would be the closest thing to the quality of food picked from your garden. No matter which source I pick there will still be a big descrepency. Depending on region and seasons prices can decrease (or even increase) Around here you pay a premium for local berries at the grocery store (similiar to that at our local farmers market)

    Aaron, fennel is a good example I would imagine it would fall pretty high with the rest of the herbs.


  40. links for 2010-06-15 « Free Hogg Says:

    [...] The most profitable plants in your vegetable garden (tags: garden) Leave a Comment [...]


  41. Top 10 Links of the Week: 6/11/10 – 6/17/10 — Cooking Grand Says:

    [...] Cheap Vegetable Gardener: The Most Profitable Plants in Your Vegetable Garden Good: leafy greens and herbs. Okay: cucumbers and tomatillos. Bad: cabbage. Poor cabbage. It ain’t get no love, never. [...]


  42. Studio G – Garden Design & Landscape Design inspiration » Top Five Most Profitable Plants in your Vegetable Garden Says:

    [...] [...]


  43. Kimberly E Says:

    interesting enough, but who eats that much cilantro!!


  44. News Roundup Says:

    [...] THE MOST PROFITABLE PLANTS IN YOUR VEGETABLE GARDEN [...]


  45. Lizbet Says:

    The value in growing your own veggies is partially the price, more valuable is knowing who’s hands have touched it in the process of it getting to your plate and what is has or hasn’t had sprayed or waxed on it.


Leave a Reply

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Please leave these two fields as-is: